National Coalition to

Abolish the Death Penalty

90 million Americans believe the death penalty is wrong. We mobilize them to end the death penalty state by state.
Join the Movementnavigateright

Do We Have a Criminal Justice System Designed to Keep US Safe?

Our broken justice system begins with a prevailing approach to policing that disproportionately targets communities of color.  Such focused attention by law enforcement has resulted in 60% of our prison population being comprised of people of color who receive longer sentences than their white counterparts. Finally, it ends with the ultimate and most disturbing of all of its disparities — unequal death penalty sentencing.

Some, such as Professor Michelle Alexander (author of The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness) argue that our current system of justice does not operate to keep communities safe because it was never intended to be, and has not functioned as, a system designed to prevent violence and care for those who are harmed.

Consider these statistics:

Alexander and others posit, with historical support, that the criminal justice system was originally designed to control the activities and movement of the slaves and freed men and women. Judge Leon Higginbotham, in his book In the Matter of Color, documents disparate sentences based on the race of the victim and the race of the perpetrator, including the sentence of death.

Alexander takes this analysis to the next level by arguing that the cumulative effect of our current system of justice operates to impose restrictions on the movements, economic standing, educational opportunity and political enfranchisement that are every bit as restrictive as the Jim Crow laws that have since been outlawed by the Constitution.

So it is not surprising that we find that our current criminal justice system does not protect people of color adequately; does not provide victims of crime in communities of color with equal access to resources and services; and imposes disproportionately harsh sentences on people of color, particularly when the victim of a crime is white.

Alexander observes, “It’s easy to be completely unaware that this vast new system of racial and social control has emerged…  Unlike in Jim Crow days, there were no ‘Whites Only’ signs. This system is out of sight, out of mind.”

David Harris of the Charles Hamilton Institute makes a similar point, noting that the U.S.’s criminal justice system has legitimized and normalized death sentences based on race, eliminating the need for lynch mobs.  He states “[L]ynchings often took the form not of frenzied killings but of deliberate, purposeful extensions of the administration of justice.  Blacks were eliminated from juries, and courts meted out disproportionately harsh sentences to black defendants…  Once new systems of disenfranchisement, debt peonage and segregation were firmly in place, mob violence gradually declined.”

What is clear is that the current system is broken and the burdens of its failures fall most heavily and unfairly on communities of color. There must be a fundamental change in the system.

Citations

1 http://sentencingproject.org/doc/publications/rd_ICCPR%20Race%20and%20Justice%20Shadow%20Report.pdf

 

2 http://www.sentencingproject.org/template/page.cfm?id=122

3 http://www.sentencingproject.org/template/page.cfm?id=133

4 http://www.sentencingproject.org/template/page.cfm?id=122

5 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/07/books/michelle-alexanders-new-jim-crow-raises-drug-law-debates.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0